To check if AI tools are recommending competitors instead of you, ask ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Mode the same questions a real customer would ask, using your city and service, and note who gets mentioned, how they are described, and whether your business appears at all.
Why this matters more than it used to
More people are starting their research with AI assistants rather than a traditional search, and Google’s own AI Mode and AI Overviews now shape what many users see first on standard searches too [1](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/appearance/ai-features). If a competitor is consistently recommended instead of you in these answers, it can affect calls and leads even before someone visits your website.
A simple test you can run in 20 minutes
Step 1: Write real customer questions
Use the phrasing an actual customer would type, not keyword-style phrases. For example: "best plumber in [city] for emergency repairs" rather than "plumber emergency city."
Step 2: Ask each tool the same set of questions
- ChatGPT (with web search/browsing enabled)
- Google AI Mode and a standard Google search to see if an AI Overview appears
- Gemini
Step 3: Record what comes back
- Is your business mentioned at all?
- Are the details about your business accurate — hours, services, location?
- Which competitors are mentioned, and in what order?
- What language is used to describe each business?
What to do if a competitor is being recommended over you
First, check whether the competitor simply has clearer, more specific content and a more complete Google Business Profile — this is usually the actual explanation, not a mysterious AI preference. Since AI features draw from the same indexed content used for regular search, improving your own fundamentals is the direct way to close the gap [2](https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/ai-optimization-guide).
- Compare your Google Business Profile completeness to theirs
- Compare how specifically your website answers the exact question you tested
- Check whether they have more recent reviews or third-party mentions
Next steps for your business
- Build a short list of 5-10 real customer questions
- Test them across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Google AI Mode
- Note any inaccurate information about your business and correct it at the source
- Strengthen the specific pages or profile sections where competitors are stronger
Want our team to keep watch for you?
Our AI Marketing team can turn this into a plan for your business.
Explore AI Marketing